Laurel or Yanny?

Laurel, obviously.

You’ve probably already heard about this. A sound recording that sounds like someone saying Laurel to some, and Yanny to others. It’s the successor to the dress, the one which appeared to be either black and blue, or white and gold.

With the dress, most people could see it both ways. You might look at it and see it clearly as blue and black, only to turn around and back again to see a clearly white-and-gold dress.

The Laurel or Yanny debate though, seems to be much more clearcut. People either hear one or the other, but usually not both. I played the clip on a loop yesterday, and heard Laurel again and again and again. And again.

I was surprised that I could only hear Laurel, and not recognise Yanny in there at all. I know that seemingly different words aren’t so distinct when you really listen to them, and we’re not always the best at picking up the exact details of what we hear. Usually that’s not a problem when we’re in conversation or watching a film, because we can roughly predict what the person is going to say because of the context. We know they’re not going to use completely unexpected words, so we hear most of the word, and our brains fill in the rest automatically based on our expectations.

Where this process fails us a little is with songs. There words are used differently, because they have to conform to the rhythm of the song, and of course because the songwriter might use a little more artistic licence in how they put words together. This is why we hear so many mondegreens: misheard song lyrics. Mondegreens are funny and interesting and funny in their own right, but they’re also a useful way to demonstrate how seemingly distinct words and phrases can actually sound very similar, when we’re lacking the context to make sense of what we’re hearing. Two words might seem superficially very different, but actually utilise very similar mouth and tongue movements to pronounce them.

I thought this might be the story behind Laurel/Yanny, and I expected at any moment to suddenly start hearing Yanny, like when you stare at one of those pictures and suddenly start seeing the old woman instead of the young woman, or the duck instead of the rabbit.

But when that didn’t happen, I became suspicious, and looked up the story behind the file. First of all, I came across this tweet demonstrating that those who can better detect higher frequencies will hear Yanny, while the rest of us with simpler ears hear Laurel.

However, it’s not simply a case that when we say Laurel, the higher frequencies of that utterance sound like Yanny. No-one’s quite sure where the clip comes from, but it seems to have been digitally manipulated to basically merge the two sounds together and create a deliberately divisive sound that a human wouldn’t naturally produce.

So whether you hear Yanny or Laurel, you’re not wrong. But if you hear Yanny, it’s worth considering that you might be a dog.

5 thoughts on “Laurel or Yanny?

  1. I heard nothing but yanny the first time I heard it. But now with your recordings today I hear nothing but laurel. When I hear one I can’t seem to hear the other one at all–not even with the tone changes in the second recording. Makes no sense. But they were both clear as a bell when I heard them. ????

    Like

  2. I heard both. Not at first. I heard Yanny. Now I seem to hear Yanny first and then I can tune in to Laurel if I hear it repeated. If I listen to it in the dark, I hear only Laurel. Not sure why that makes a difference, but it does.

    Like

  3. It’s Laurel and the damned dress is blue. By the way, I’m giving out superhero names over at mydangblog, and I have dubbed you “Lexicon”. Your superpower is the ability to transform into any noun you choose. You will be a tremendous asset to our superhero posse.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s